Line cookie sheets with wax paper to keep things tidy.
Gather small bowls and fill them with your spooky decorating materials.
Butter your bamboo skewers before impaling sticky marshmallows. Just 1/4 teaspoon coats a whole bunch of skewers.
For younger kids, use lollipop sticks or straws instead of bamboo skewers. If using straws, snip the ends at an angle to make inserting them easier.
For gelatin-coated marshmallows, dip marshmallows in water, blot with a paper towel and roll in gelatin powder.
For homemade colored sugar, toss white sugar into a jar or bag, add food coloring, start with 6 drops and add more as needed, and shake until vibrantly hued. Roll marshmallows in the sugar.
For candy melts, melt them in the microwave in 30-second increments, stirring in between. Add a teaspoon of shortening or coconut oil if desired, then dip marshmallows for a smooth coating. Let them harden on wax paper.
Decorate the marshmallows as Frankenstein’s Monsters, Pumpkin Faces, Mummies, Ghosts, Googly Monsters or Bloodshot Eyeballs.
Thread the decorated marshmallows onto the prepared skewers, lollipop sticks or straws.
For toddlers, skip the sticks and serve decorated marshmallows on a festive plate instead. Keep an eye on sugar eyeballs and supervise young children.